Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni

Save this recipe on:

I’ve made plenty of steak dinners in my time, but this Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni is on a whole different level. The steak is seared to a perfect crust and then basted with a rich garlic herb butter that adds a punch of flavor. But what really takes it over the top is that dreamy rigatoni—coated in a cheesy, creamy Cajun sauce that clings to every curve of the pasta. It’s bold, decadent, and absolutely unforgettable.

This dish is perfect for a date night at home, a special weekend meal, or whenever you want to impress someone without making it overly complicated. The Cajun seasoning ties both the steak and the pasta together beautifully, while the creamy sauce mellows out the heat just enough to keep you coming back for another bite. I promise, once you try this, it’s going to be hard to go back to regular steak and pasta again.

---

Why You’ll Love This Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni

You get the best of both worlds: perfectly cooked, juicy steak and comforting, velvety pasta. The Cajun seasoning adds just enough spice to make it interesting, while the garlic butter and cheese provide that rich, luxurious finish. Whether you’re cooking for a crowd or just treating yourself, this dish is pure satisfaction on a plate.

---

What Cut of Steak Works Best for Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak?

For this recipe, I usually reach for a ribeye or New York strip—something well-marbled that can handle a good sear and stay tender and juicy inside. The fat in those cuts pairs beautifully with the garlic butter and Cajun seasoning, adding richness that complements the creamy rigatoni perfectly. You can also go with a sirloin if you’re looking for something a bit leaner but still flavorful.

If you’re feeling fancy, a filet mignon works too, but just be mindful of cooking times since it’s more delicate and doesn’t need as much time in the pan.

---

Options for Substitutions

If you’re out of certain ingredients or just want to switch things up a bit, here are a few easy swaps that still keep the spirit of this dish alive:

• Steak Substitute: Try grilled chicken breast or shrimp for a lighter spin. The Cajun seasoning still shines.
• Pasta Swap: No rigatoni? Go with penne, rotini, or even fettuccine. Just pick a pasta that can hold onto the creamy sauce.
• Cajun Seasoning Alternative: If you’re sensitive to spice, reduce the Cajun mix and add a little smoked paprika and Italian herbs for flavor without the heat.
• Dairy-Free Option: Use plant-based butter and coconut cream in place of the cheese sauce ingredients for a surprisingly rich and creamy finish.
• Cheese Variation: Parmesan and mozzarella are great staples, but smoked gouda or sharp cheddar can give the sauce a deeper, more complex flavor.

---

Ingredients for This Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni

• Ribeye or New York Strip Steak
  A thick, well-marbled cut is ideal—it stays juicy and flavorful and sears beautifully.
• Rigatoni Pasta
  Its ridged surface and tubular shape are perfect for catching every bit of the creamy, cheesy sauce.
• Heavy Cream
  Creates the rich, velvety base for the sauce that clings perfectly to the pasta.
• Garlic (minced)
  Fresh garlic adds depth and sharpness to both the butter for the steak and the sauce.
• Butter
  Used to baste the steak and enrich the flavor—it’s also what makes the garlic butter truly irresistible.
• Cajun Seasoning
  This is the heart of the flavor profile. It brings a smoky, spicy kick that ties the dish together.
• Parmesan Cheese
  Adds saltiness and umami to the sauce, making it creamy, cheesy, and savory all at once.
• Mozzarella Cheese
  Gives the sauce that gooey, stretchy element and smooth mouthfeel.
• Olive Oil
  Used to get that perfect sear on the steak, locking in flavor and moisture.
• Salt and Cracked Black Pepper
  Essential for seasoning both the steak and the pasta water—never skip this.
• Fresh Parsley or Chives (optional)
  Adds a touch of brightness and freshness to balance the richness.

---

Step 1: Prepare the Steak

Take your steak out of the fridge and let it come to room temperature for about 30 minutes. Pat it dry with paper towels, then season generously on both sides with salt, black pepper, and Cajun seasoning.

---

Step 2: Boil the Rigatoni

Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil. Add rigatoni and cook until al dente, following the package instructions. Reserve about 1 cup of pasta water before draining—this helps adjust the sauce later if needed.

---

Step 3: Sear the Steak

Heat a heavy skillet (preferably cast iron) over medium-high heat. Add a tablespoon of olive oil. When the oil is hot and shimmering, sear the steak for 3–4 minutes on each side until a deep crust forms. Reduce heat slightly and add butter and minced garlic. Baste the steak with the melted garlic butter for another minute or two. Remove from pan and let it rest.

---

Step 4: Make the Creamy Cajun Sauce

In the same skillet (no need to clean it—those steak bits are flavor gold), lower the heat and pour in the heavy cream. Stir in Parmesan, mozzarella, and a bit more Cajun seasoning. Let it simmer gently until the cheese melts and the sauce thickens.

---

Step 5: Combine Pasta with Sauce

Add the cooked rigatoni directly into the skillet with the sauce. Toss everything together until the pasta is fully coated. Add a splash of reserved pasta water if the sauce is too thick.

---

Step 6: Slice and Serve

Slice the rested steak into thick strips. Plate the creamy rigatoni next to the steak, drizzle any leftover garlic butter on top, and garnish with chopped parsley or chives.

---

How Long to Cook the Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni

Cooking time can vary slightly depending on your steak cut and desired doneness, but here’s a general guide:

• Steak:
  Searing takes about 3–4 minutes per side, with an additional 1–2 minutes of basting in garlic butter. Let it rest for 5–10 minutes before slicing.
• Pasta:
  Rigatoni usually cooks in 10–12 minutes until al dente.
• Sauce:
  The Cajun cheese sauce comes together quickly—5–7 minutes on low heat to melt the cheese and thicken up.

Total cook time: around 30–35 minutes from start to finish.

---

Tips for Perfect Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni

• Let the steak rest:
  Resting after searing keeps it juicy and allows the juices to redistribute instead of spilling out when you cut it.
• Use freshly grated cheese:
  Pre-shredded cheese often contains anti-caking agents that don’t melt as smoothly. Fresh cheese = creamier sauce.
• Don’t overcook the pasta:
  Slightly undercook it (al dente) since it will continue cooking in the sauce for a perfect texture.
• Control the Cajun spice:
  Cajun seasoning varies by brand. Start small—you can always add more, but you can’t take it out.
• Reserve that pasta water:
  A splash of starchy water will loosen the sauce if it thickens too much and helps it cling better to the rigatoni.
• Use a meat thermometer for steak:
  Aim for 130°F (54°C) for medium-rare or 140°F (60°C) for medium. It’s more accurate than guessing.
• Deglaze the pan if needed:
  If your pan is too dry after cooking steak, add a splash of pasta water or cream before starting the sauce to lift the flavorful bits.

---

Watch Out for These Mistakes While Cooking

• Skipping the steak rest time
  Cutting into the steak too soon will cause all those flavorful juices to run out. Be patient—let it rest at least 5 minutes.
• Using cold steak straight from the fridge
  Cold meat won’t sear properly. Always bring your steak to room temperature before cooking to ensure even cooking and better browning.
• Overheating the cream
  If the cream boils too hard, the cheese can separate, turning your sauce grainy. Keep the heat low and stir gently.
• Forgetting to salt the pasta water
  It’s your only chance to season the pasta itself. The water should taste like the sea.
• Overloading with Cajun seasoning
  It’s tempting to go big, but too much will overpower everything and make the dish too salty or spicy. Build flavor gradually.
• Cutting steak too thin or too early
  Thick slices keep the meat juicy and let the steak shine alongside the creamy pasta.
• Using low-quality cheese
  The better the cheese, the richer and smoother your sauce. Go for real Parmesan, not the powdered kind.

---

What to Serve With Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni?

Garlic Bread or Cheesy Breadsticks

Perfect for soaking up every last bit of that creamy Cajun sauce.

Simple Green Salad

A crisp salad with a light vinaigrette helps balance out the richness of the dish.

Roasted Broccoli or Asparagus

The smoky flavors from the roast veggies complement the garlic butter steak beautifully.

A Glass of Red Wine

Something like a cabernet or syrah brings out the flavors in both the steak and the Cajun spices.

Sauteed Garlic Spinach

Quick, garlicky, and just bitter enough to contrast the creaminess of the pasta.

Cucumber and Tomato Salad

A fresh, cold side to refresh your palate between bites of the rich main dish.

Lemon Butter Green Beans

Bright and slightly tangy, these cut through the bold flavors of the meal.

Burrata with Cherry Tomatoes

If you’re leaning into indulgence, this chilled creamy starter is a luxurious match.

---

Storage Instructions

Got leftovers? You’re in luck—this dish holds up surprisingly well.

• Refrigeration:
  Store any leftover steak and pasta in separate airtight containers if possible. This keeps the steak from getting soggy. Both will last for up to 3 days in the fridge.
• Reheating:
  Reheat the pasta gently over low heat on the stovetop with a splash of cream or milk to loosen up the sauce. For the steak, a quick sear in a hot pan or a few minutes in the oven at 300°F (150°C) helps maintain that juicy texture.
• Freezing:
  The steak can be frozen for up to 2 months, but the creamy rigatoni is best enjoyed fresh or refrigerated only. Cream-based sauces tend to separate when frozen.

---

Estimated Nutrition

Per serving (based on 4 servings total)

• Calories: ~820 kcal
• Protein: ~38g
• Fat: ~52g
• Saturated Fat: ~26g
• Unsaturated Fat: ~23g
• Trans Fat: ~1g
• Carbohydrates: ~48g
• Fiber: ~3g
• Sugar: ~3g
• Sodium: ~870mg
• Cholesterol: ~160mg

Note: These values are estimates and may vary depending on portion sizes and specific brands used.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I use if I don’t have Cajun seasoning?

You can make a quick homemade version using paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, oregano, thyme, cayenne, and a bit of salt and pepper. Or swap it for blackened seasoning for a similar flavor profile.

Can I make this dish ahead of time?

Yes—but for best results, cook the steak fresh and prep the pasta sauce separately. Reheat gently before combining everything just before serving.

Is this recipe spicy?

It has a mild to medium kick, depending on your Cajun seasoning. If you’re sensitive to spice, reduce the amount or add a splash of cream to mellow it out.

Can I make this dish gluten-free?

Absolutely. Use your favorite gluten-free rigatoni or pasta, and make sure your Cajun seasoning is certified gluten-free.

What kind of cheese works best for the sauce?

A blend of Parmesan for sharpness and Mozzarella for creaminess is perfect. You can also try smoked gouda or cheddar for a twist.

How do I know when the steak is done?

Use a meat thermometer:

• 130°F (54°C) = Medium-rare
• 140°F (60°C) = Medium
  Let it rest for 5–10 minutes before slicing.

Can I use milk instead of heavy cream?

You can, but the sauce will be thinner and less rich. Add a tablespoon of butter or cream cheese to help thicken it up if needed.

How do I avoid overcooking the steak?

Don’t crowd the pan, use high heat for the initial sear, and always rest the meat. A thermometer helps ensure perfect doneness.

---

Conclusion

Cheesy Cajun Garlic Butter Steak with Creamy Rigatoni isn’t just a dinner—it’s a full-blown experience. From the sizzle of the searing steak to the silky, bold Cajun cream sauce hugging every bite of rigatoni, this dish balances comfort and flavor like few others can. Whether you’re making it to impress or just craving something indulgent, this recipe hits all the right notes.

It’s rich without being overwhelming, spicy without overpowering, and easy enough to whip up on a weeknight with the payoff of a restaurant-level meal. Give it a go—you might just find your new favorite dinner idea.

---

Print

Save this recipe on: