Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Save this recipe on:

There’s something incredibly comforting about a creamy, rich, and nutty dessert, and Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie delivers on all fronts. This decadent pie features a silky peanut butter filling layered over a buttery graham cracker crust, topped with a luscious whipped cream topping and drizzled with extra peanut butter for a perfect finish. Every bite is a delightful mix of sweet, salty, and creamy goodness that melts in your mouth.

I love how this pie captures the essence of Amish baking—simple ingredients, rich flavors, and a homemade taste that feels like a warm hug. Whether you’re serving it at a family gathering, holiday dinner, or just indulging in a sweet treat, this pie is guaranteed to impress. Plus, there’s no need to turn on the oven, making it an easy no-bake dessert that comes together effortlessly.

---

Why You’ll Love This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

• Rich and Creamy: The filling is ultra-smooth with the perfect balance of peanut butter and sweetness.
• No-Bake Dessert: Ideal for warm days when you don’t want to heat up the kitchen.
• Easy to Make: Simple ingredients and straightforward steps make this a stress-free treat.
• Crowd-Pleaser: Whether for a potluck, holiday, or casual dessert, it’s always a hit.
• Versatile: Customize with chocolate drizzle, chopped peanuts, or a cookie crust for extra flair.

---

What Kind of Peanut Butter Should I Use?

The key to achieving the perfect texture and flavor in Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is choosing the right peanut butter. I recommend using creamy, no-stir peanut butter for the smoothest consistency. Brands like Jif or Skippy work well because they blend seamlessly into the filling without separating.

If you prefer a more natural option, be sure to stir it thoroughly before using, as natural peanut butter tends to separate, which can affect the texture of the pie. Crunchy peanut butter can also be used for added texture, but the filling won’t be as silky smooth.

---

Options for Substitutions

If you need to tweak the recipe to fit dietary needs or preferences, here are some great alternatives:

• Crust Options: Swap out the graham cracker crust for an Oreo crust for a chocolatey contrast, or use a shortbread crust for a buttery twist.
• Peanut Butter Alternatives: Almond butter or cashew butter can be used for a different flavor, though they will alter the taste slightly.
• Dairy-Free Version: Use coconut cream instead of heavy cream and a dairy-free whipped topping.
• Gluten-Free Crust: Opt for a gluten-free graham cracker or almond flour crust.
• Lower Sugar Option: Use a natural peanut butter with no added sugar and replace powdered sugar with a sugar substitute like monk fruit or stevia.

---

Ingredients for This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Each ingredient in this pie plays a crucial role in creating its rich, creamy, and indulgent flavor. Here’s what you’ll need and why it matters:

• Graham cracker crumbs – Forms the base of the pie, providing a slightly crunchy and buttery contrast to the creamy filling.
• Melted butter – Helps bind the graham cracker crust together, giving it a firm and delicious texture.
• Cream cheese – Adds a slight tanginess and contributes to the rich, smooth texture of the filling.
• Powdered sugar – Sweetens the filling without the graininess of granulated sugar, keeping it silky.
• Peanut butter – The star of the show, bringing that signature nutty flavor that makes this pie irresistible.
• Vanilla extract – Enhances the overall sweetness and deepens the flavor profile.
• Heavy whipping cream – Whipped into peaks to create a light, airy, and creamy consistency.
• Whipped topping – Provides an extra layer of fluffiness and stability to the pie.
• Peanut butter drizzle (optional) – For an added decorative touch and extra peanut butter goodness on top.

With these simple ingredients, you’ll have a decadent pie that’s full of rich, nutty flavor and creamy texture!

---

How Long to Cook the Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

One of the best things about this pie is that it’s completely no-bake! That means no oven time—just mix, assemble, and let it chill. For the best texture, refrigerate the pie for at least 4 hours, but if you can wait, chilling it overnight will give you an even firmer, creamier consistency.

If you’re in a rush, you can speed things up by placing the pie in the freezer for about 1 hour, but be sure to let it sit at room temperature for a few minutes before slicing.

---

Tips for the Perfect Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

• Use full-fat ingredients – Cream cheese, heavy cream, and peanut butter with a good fat content help create the smoothest and richest filling.
• Chill the crust before adding the filling – This helps it set properly and prevents crumbling when you slice the pie.
• Whip the heavy cream to stiff peaks – This keeps the filling light and fluffy rather than dense.
• Fold the whipped cream gently – Overmixing can deflate the airiness and make the filling too heavy.
• Refrigerate overnight for best results – This ensures the pie is fully set and enhances the flavors.
• Warm the peanut butter for drizzling – If adding a peanut butter drizzle, slightly heat it in the microwave for a smoother pour.
• Use a sharp knife for clean slices – Wiping the knife between cuts prevents the creamy filling from smearing.

With these tips, your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie will turn out silky smooth, beautifully layered, and absolutely irresistible!

---

Watch Out for These Mistakes While Cooking

Even though this pie is easy to make, a few common mistakes can affect the final result. Here’s what to avoid:

• Using natural peanut butter without stirring – If using natural peanut butter, mix it thoroughly to prevent separation, which can make the filling grainy.
• Skipping the chilling time – The pie needs at least 4 hours in the fridge to set properly. Cutting it too soon may result in a runny filling.
• Overmixing the whipped cream – Folding too aggressively can deflate the whipped cream, making the filling dense instead of light and airy.
• Not pressing the crust firmly – If the crust isn’t packed down well, it may crumble when slicing the pie. Use a flat-bottomed glass to press it evenly.
• Using low-fat ingredients – Full-fat cream cheese and heavy whipping cream are crucial for a rich and creamy texture. Low-fat substitutes can result in a runny or less flavorful pie.
• Freezing for too long – While the freezer can help speed up the setting process, leaving the pie in too long can make it too hard to slice properly.

---

What to Serve With Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

This pie is indulgent on its own, but pairing it with the right sides and beverages can elevate the experience.

1. A Glass of Cold Milk

Nothing pairs better with peanut butter than a classic glass of milk! The creamy texture balances the pie’s richness.

2. Hot Coffee or Espresso

The bitterness of coffee contrasts beautifully with the sweetness of the pie, making for a perfect after-dinner treat.

3. Chocolate Drizzle or Sauce

A drizzle of warm chocolate sauce over the pie adds an extra layer of decadence.

4. Salted Caramel Sauce

A touch of salted caramel enhances the sweet and salty flavors of the peanut butter.

5. Crushed Peanuts for Crunch

Sprinkle some crushed roasted peanuts on top for added texture and a nutty boost.

6. A Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream

The cool, creamy contrast of ice cream makes this dessert even more luxurious.

7. Fresh Sliced Bananas

Bananas and peanut butter are a classic duo, adding a fruity twist to the pie.

8. Whipped Cream with a Dusting of Cocoa Powder

A light cocoa dusting enhances the visual appeal and adds a subtle chocolate flavor.

With these pairings, your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie will be the star of any dessert table!

---

Storage Instructions

To keep your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie fresh and delicious, proper storage is key.

• Refrigeration: Store the pie in the refrigerator, covered with plastic wrap or foil, for up to 4-5 days. The crust may soften slightly over time, but the flavors will remain rich and creamy.
• Freezing: If you want to keep it longer, freeze the pie for up to 2 months. Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and then in aluminum foil to prevent freezer burn. When ready to serve, let it thaw in the fridge overnight.
• Serving After Freezing: For a firmer, ice-cream-like texture, you can eat it slightly frozen. If you prefer a softer consistency, let it sit at room temperature for 10-15 minutes before slicing.

---

Estimated Nutrition

While this pie is a delicious treat, it is also quite indulgent! Here’s an estimate per slice (based on 8 servings):

• Calories: ~450-500 kcal
• Carbohydrates: ~40g
• Protein: ~9g
• Fat: ~30g
• Saturated Fat: ~15g
• Sugar: ~25g
• Fiber: ~2g
• Sodium: ~250mg

For a lighter version, you can use reduced-fat cream cheese, a sugar substitute, or a smaller portion of the crust and toppings.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy?

Yes! Crunchy peanut butter will add a bit of texture to the filling, though the pie won’t be as silky smooth. If you love the crunch, go for it!

2. How long does this pie need to chill before serving?

At least 4 hours in the fridge, but overnight is best for a firm, sliceable texture.

3. Can I make this pie ahead of time?

Absolutely! This is a great make-ahead dessert. You can prepare it 1-2 days in advance and keep it refrigerated until ready to serve.

4. What’s the best way to slice the pie neatly?

Use a sharp knife and wipe it clean between slices. If the pie is very firm, let it sit at room temperature for a few minutes before cutting.

5. Can I make this pie gluten-free?

Yes! Simply swap out the graham cracker crust for a gluten-free alternative, or use crushed gluten-free cookies instead.

6. What can I use instead of whipped topping?

You can replace it with homemade whipped cream by beating 1 cup of heavy cream with 2 tablespoons of powdered sugar until stiff peaks form.

7. Can I add chocolate to this pie?

Definitely! You can mix melted chocolate into the filling, use an Oreo crust, or drizzle chocolate sauce on top for a peanut butter-chocolate combo.

8. How can I make this pie less sweet?

Use natural peanut butter with no added sugar, and reduce the powdered sugar slightly. You can also use a sugar substitute like monk fruit sweetener.

---

Conclusion

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a dreamy, no-bake dessert that combines creamy peanut butter, a buttery graham cracker crust, and a light whipped topping for the perfect balance of rich and airy. It’s an easy, crowd-pleasing treat that’s perfect for holidays, potlucks, or just because you’re craving something sweet.

---

Print

Save this recipe on: